[sword-devel] FreCrampon module: versification problem for Malachi 4
1370-577 at onlinehome.de
Wed Feb 4 00:44:09 MST 2009
The original versification is not lost. The versification information is in
the <WTH> tag like "<WTH3-19>".
Chris Little-2 wrote:
> Any versification that is fundamentally different from what I used to
> produce the existing FreCrampon module is an incorrect versification.
> That is not to discount the possibility of minor errors in versification
> in my own edition, but my module's versification is fundamentally
> correct and any attempt to push this text into a KJV versification is
> We want to represent the actual text, as one would find it in a printed
> edition, as well as possible, given various technical limitations. I can
> understand the desire to perform lookup based on another versification
> and get the expected parallel passage (e.g. lookup a verse in KJV:Mal.4
> and get a verse in Mal.3 of FreCrampon). Plenty of software does that.
> But re-versifying the base text from its native versification to a
> foreign one is not reasonable/not acceptable/not an option. We don't do
> that and never will.
> (NB: We have texts that have been re-versified in this undesirable
> fashion, but the change to a source without this kind of versification
> mangling is considered a valuable upgrade in quality.)
> Jens_G wrote:
>> I have a *.vpl with no error in versnumbering.
>> Peter von Kaehne wrote:
>>> David Haslam wrote:
>>>> Selecting Malachi 4 in FreCrampon gives an empty text display.
>>>> Selecting Malachi 3 shows that the text for Mal 4:1-6 is included
>>>> Why is this? Can this be corrected?
>>>> btw. It causes errors when tools such as MOD2IMP are used.
>>>> -- David
>>> This is one of many modules which will benefit from the new gen book
>>> It appears that the FreCrampon uses the same scheme as Luther bibles in
>>> The same problem there.
>>> sword-devel mailing list: sword-devel at crosswire.org
>>> Instructions to unsubscribe/change your settings at above page
> sword-devel mailing list: sword-devel at crosswire.org
> Instructions to unsubscribe/change your settings at above page
View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/FreCrampon-module%3A-versification-problem-for-Malachi-4-tp21241698p21825803.html
Sent from the SWORD Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
More information about the sword-devel