[bt-devel] close button on bookshelf dialog

[Gary Holmlund]

Jaak,

You reverted my addition of a close button to the Bookshelf manager 
dialog without any discussion. Both Martin and I have sent email to have 
a discussion about this. Still no discussion. I believe a close button 
belongs on this dialog for usability reasons alone, even if a close icon 
is in the upper right corner. What do you say about this?

Gary

On 06/21/2011 06:12 PM, Gary Holmlund wrote:
> On 06/21/2011 11:52 AM, Martin Gruner wrote:
>> Hi Jaak,
>>
>> Regarding your commit:
>> http://gitorious.org/bibletime/bibletime/commit/958553892c6e30133e6c0b0cf4c17217a727ca33 
>>
>>
>> I think every dialog should have a close button, so I think window flags
>> and a close button should be combined.
>> Do you know any dialog in a program which doesn't have an 'Ok' or
>> 'Close' button? I think that's bad usability.
>>
>> Regards, mg
> The usability was also what I was thinking when I added the close button.
>
> Also, Meego does not put any window icons on their dialogs. There is 
> no work around for closing it on Meego.
>
> Gary