[sword-devel] Programmatic assigning of sword numbers
Troy A. Griffitts
scribe at crosswire.org
Mon Sep 24 01:06:28 MST 2007
I think you should do it! :)
We actually have a "Guess at Strong's" button on our KJV2003 tagging
tool. It did pretty good and gave taggers a good starting place for
each verse, and DM, it's in JAVA! :)
Actually, the code is pretty trivial. It just uses known KJV
translation phrases and frequencies to weight likely candidates in a
verse. And like you have mentioned, since we know all the Strong's for
a single verse, and a single verse only has so many english words, the
options are narrowed significantly.
So, are you gonna do it? :)
DM Smith wrote:
> On Sep 23, 2007, at 11:09 PM, jonathon wrote:
>> DM Smith wrote:
>>> If we had a mapping of which words and or phrases in a given
>>> language mapped to a Strong's number, then one could write a
>>> program that tagged best matches.
>> That makes it sound far more easier than it is in practice.
>>> Now I've taken enough language classes to know that the effort would
>>> be imprecise. Proofreading would be necessary.
>> I've been looking at English mappings.
>> The same English word can have two or more Strong's numbers.
>> The same Strong number can have half a dozen English words.
> Yes these are some of the problems. Phrase mapping is yet another set
> of problems.
> But for a given verse, we have a limited number of words for which
> the Strong's numbers can map. This reduces the ambiguity and in some
> cases might eliminate it.
> The Strong's Lexicons sometimes list the possible mappings for a
> particular translation. If we have a translation that is fairly close
> to that, then we can use that as a hint of a constrained mapping.
> For example, we have the mapping for the KJV. We have many variants
> of the KJV at Sword without Strong's numbers. A comparison of the one
> to the other can yield the differences and applying an approximation
> mapping algorithm (bitap, for example) can produce good results.
> See a real working example of this here:
> -- DM
> sword-devel mailing list: sword-devel at crosswire.org
> Instructions to unsubscribe/change your settings at above page
More information about the sword-devel