[osis-core] rich example

[Todd Tillinghast]

Troy,

I know this is not what you are after with the rich example but looking at
the richness of the example points out the fact that it is unlikely that any
document will include ALL of the possible <w> type elements.

Any ideas on how we could represent the <w> elements in a separate document
that are not included in the scripture document itself?

Todd
----- Original Message -----
From: "Troy A. Griffitts" <scribe@crosswire.org>
To: <osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org>
Sent: Thursday, April 04, 2002 7:02 PM
Subject: Re: [osis-core] rich example


> New cut at the bottom...
>
> > Don't turn the crank just yet! With the XMLSpy missing some fairly
> > important stuff, I want to make a pass with the IBM schema validator and
> > walk through an (gasp!) analog copy tonight/early tomorrow.
>
> :)
>
> Good luck!
>
>
> > <verseStart VerseStart="John.1.1"
> > reference="HarperBibleCommentary.1988.p.1046">
> >
> > Possible, in which case we would probably want to allow several such
> > references. Hmmm, may not be the best way.
> >
> > Originally, we discussed reference as a linking mechanism for other
> > milestones and it just got put on verses without a lot of thought (on my
> > part).
> >
> > Comments from the group?
>
> I would think the link would go the other way: commentary -> Bible
>
> Is it normal to have an attribute called the same as its element?  might
> we remove VerseStart and keep reference?  It might be easier to write
> code if we have the same attribute for all these type of milestone tags:
> <chapterStart /> <verseStart /> <bookStart /> <chapterEnd /> <verseEnd
> /> <bookEnd />
>
>
> > My inclination is to take reference off of the verse milestones. There
> > are better ways to link to other materials. That would leave references
> > on the other milestones (although not as ID datatype!) to point to
> > beginning and ending material in the milestones.
>
>
>
>
> Latest cut:
> ____________________
>
>
> TR: en arXA An ho logos kai ho logos An pros ton Qeon kai Qeos An ho
> logos
> KJV: In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the
> Word was God.
>
> becomes:
>
>
> TR:
>
> <bookStart BookStart="John" /><chapterStart ChapterStart="John.1"
> /><verseStart VerseStart="John.1.1" /><w lemma="x-Strong:1722"
> morphology="x-Robinson:PREP" gloss="x-en:In"
> transliteration="x-Latin:en" ID="trw67521">en</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:746" morphology="x-Robinson:N-DSF" gloss="x-en:the
> beginning" transliteration="x-Latin:archei" ID="trw67522">arXa</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:2258" morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S" gloss="x-en:was"
> transliteration="x-Latin:ein" ID="trw67523">An</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:3056" morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM" gloss="x-en:the
> Word" transliteration="x-Latin:ho logos" ID="trw67524">ho logos</w>, <w
> lemma="x-Strong:2532" morphology="x-Robinson:CONJ" gloss="x-en:and"
> transliteration="x-Latin:kai" ID="trw67525">kai</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:3056" morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM" gloss="x-en:the
> Word" transliteration="x-Latin:ho logos" ID="trw67526">ho logos</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:2258" morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S" gloss="x-en:was"
> transliteration="x-Latin:ein" ID="trw67527">An</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:4314" morphology="x-Robinson:PREP" gloss="x-en:with"
> transliteration="x-Latin:pros" ID="trw67528">pros</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:2316" morphology="x-Robinson:N-ASM" gloss="x-en:God"
> tranliteration="ton theon" ID="trw67529">ton Qeon</w>, <w
> lemma="x-Strong:2532" morphology="x-Robinson:CONJ" gloss="x-en:and"
> transliteration="x-Latin:kai" ID="trw67530">kai</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:2316" morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM gloss="x-en:God"
> transliteration="x-Latin:theos" ID="trw67531">Qeos</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:2258" morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S" gloss="x-en:was"
> transliteration="x-Latin:ein" ID="trw67532">An</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:3056" morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM" gloss="x-en:the
> Word" transliteration="x-Latin:ho logos" ID="trw67533">ho
> logos</w><verseEnd refVerseStart="John.1.1" />
>
> KJV:
>
> <bookStart BookStart="John" /><chapterStart ChapterStart="John.1"
> /><verseStart VerseStart="John.1.1" /><w lemma="x-Strong:1722"
> morphology="x-Robinson:PREP" reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67521">In</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:746" morphology="x-Robinson:N-DSF"
> reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67522">the beginning</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:2258" morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S"
> reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67523">was</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:3056"
> morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM" reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67524">the
> Word</w>, <w lemma="x-Strong:2532" morphology="x-Robinson:CONJ"
> reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67525">and</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:3056"
> morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM" reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67526">the
> Word</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:2258" morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S"
> reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67527">was</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:4314"
> morphology="x-Robinson:PREP" reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67528">with</w>
> <w lemma="x-Strong:2316" morphology="x-Robinson:N-ASM"
> reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67529">God</w>, <w lemma="x-Strong:2532"
> morphology="x-Robinson:CONJ" reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67530">and</w> <w
> lemma="x-Strong:3056" morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM
> reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67533">the Word</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:2258"
> morphology="x-Robinson:V-IXI-3S"
> reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67532">was</w> <w lemma="x-Strong:2316"
> morphology="x-Robinson:N-NSM
> reference="TR.John.1.1.trw67531">God</w>.<verseEnd
> refVerseStart="John.1.1" />
>