[osis-core] OSISScripture_01094 with new regex. (Typo)
Patrick Durusau
osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org
Wed, 17 Apr 2002 07:46:07 -0400
Todd,
Great explanation! Unfortunately I could not follow it! ;-)
Are you saying current schema:
Does validate attributes: referenceType, milestoneID, milestoneIDREF
Does not validate xs:string content of <reference>HERE IS NOT
VALIDATED</reference>
?
Thanks!
Patrick
Todd Tillinghast wrote:
>The first sentence below should read "in elements" rather than "or
>elements"
>I am afraid I caused some confusion in my examples. I just use a file
>that looks like what I sent in the email to validate. ALL of the
>current instance of elements in OSIS use referenceType, milestoneID, and
>milestoneIDREF as attributes in elements.
>
>>-----Original Message-----
>>From: owner-osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org [mailto:owner-osis-
>>core@bibletechnologieswg.org] On Behalf Of Todd Tillinghast
>>Sent: Wednesday, April 17, 2002 6:40 AM
>>To: osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org
>>Subject: RE: [osis-core] OSISScripture_01094 with new regex.
>>
>>I am afraid I caused some confusion in my examples. I just use a file
>>that looks like what I sent in the email to validate. ALL of the
>>current instance of elements in OSIS use referenceType, milestoneID,
>>
>and
>
>>milestoneIDREF as attributes or elements.
>>
>>So is valid
>><reference refStart="Gen.1.20-22">Genesis 1:20-22</reference>
>>However, while this is valid what you probably mean is
>><reference targetStart="Gen.1.20" targetEnd"Gen.1.22">Genesis
>>1:20-22</reference>
>>The reason "Gen.1.20-22" is valid is for cases where the people
>>
>creating
>
>>the reference system did not have a distinct verse 20, 21 and 22 but
>>rather choose to call the set of text traditionally know as verse 20,
>>21, and 22 by a new name 20-22. The new name could as easily be
>>
>called
>
>>"elephant" and the name that appears to be a range in not. I encoders
>>want to express a range the should use the form shown second above.
>>
>(If
>
>>you have a printed TEV Bible, Gen.20.17-18 and Matt.1.2-6a are good
>>examples of these cases.)
>>
>>Further, the reference system is defined in the "work" attribute of
>>
>the
>
>><text> element. If the reference system of a reference is not the one
>>specified in <text> then the reference system must be included in the
>>reference attribute.
>>
>>Ex from Josephus ant.2.3.1:
>>
>><text work="Josephus">
>>...
>> <div type="x-section" refStart="ant.2.3.1">
>> <p>1. NOW these ...<note noteType="explanation"><p>....
>>also in all our copies, <reference
>>refStart="Bible.Cath..Gen.37.10">Genesis
>>37:10</reference>.</p></note>...</p>
>> </div>
>>...
>></text>
>>
>>Since the default reference system is declared as "Josephus" in <text>
>>the references to Josephus can default the reference system but the
>>references to the Bible must specify the reference system. It would
>>also be valid for the Josephus references to be expressed as
>>"Josephus..ant.2.3.1". Note that ".." separates the reference system
>>from the simple part of the reference. If ".." is not present then
>>
>the
>
>>reference system is assumed to be the default reference system.
>>
>>
>>To reduce the confusion the following are valid:
>><reference targetStart="Bible.KJV..Gen"/>
>><reference targetStart="Bible.KJV..Gen" targetEnd="Bible.KJV..Rev/>
>>(NOTE: This is a range that includes the entire KJV Bible.
>><reference targetStart="Bible.KJV.A..Gen.a-a.1.1-1"/>
>><reference targetStart="Bible.B..Gen"/>
>><reference targetStart="Gen.20.16">Genesis 20:16</reference>
>><reference targetStart="Gen.20.13" targetEnd="Gen.20.16">Genesis
>>20:13-16</reference> (NOTE: This is a range.)
>><reference targetStart="Gen.20.17-18"/> (NOTE: this is not a range!)
>><reference targetStart="Gen.20.13" targetEnd="Gen.20.17-18"/> (NOTE:
>>this is a range from the verse known as Gen 20:13 to the verse known
>>
>as
>
>>Gen 20:17-18.)
>><reference targetStart="Gen.20.17-18.Q-1"/>
>><text work="Bible.TEV"/>
>><text work="Bible.XYZ"/>
>><text work="Bible.h"/>
>><text work="Bible.TEV.1998"/>
>><text work="Bible.1"/>
>>
>>Hope that this clears things up.
>>
>>Let me know if I missed something or just made things more fuzzy.
>>
>>Todd
>>
>>>-----Original Message-----
>>>From: owner-osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org [mailto:owner-osis-
>>>core@bibletechnologieswg.org] On Behalf Of Patrick Durusau
>>>Sent: Wednesday, April 17, 2002 5:48 AM
>>>To: osis-core@bibletechnologieswg.org
>>>Subject: Re: [osis-core] OSISScripture_01094 with new regex.
>>>
>>>Troy,
>>>
>>>I will be calling Todd today about the regex problem on reference.
>>>
>>>Troy A. Griffitts wrote:
>>>
>>>>No! My bad! Your original assumption was correct: attribute
>>>>
>value
>
>>+
>>
>>>>display text container, vs. Todd's syntax. The ':' int the
>>>>
>attribute
>
>>>>value was accidental. rev v.00002 below
>>>>
>>>><ref refID="Gen.1.20-22">Genesis 1:20-22</ref>
>>>>
>>>Thanks for catching this rather serious problem!
>>>
>>>Try the attached revision and see if that fixes the problem. There
>>>should be NO validation of the string between the <ref refID=....>
>>>
>NO
>
>>>Validation here </ref>.
>>>
>>>Patrick
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>>Patrick Durusau wrote:
>>>>
>>>>>Troy,
>>>>>
>>>>>Sorry, the question was the use of a ":" in the attribute value?
>>>>>
>>>>>If so, no, is it not allowed.
>>>>>
>>>>>Patrick
>>>>>
>>>>>Troy A. Griffitts wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>>>I LOVE examples, as I am not up on the current XML lingo.
>>>>>>I don't understand the examples below.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>Are we saying that we're not having anything like:
>>>>>>
>>>>>><ref refID="Gen.1:20-22">Genesis 1:20-22</ref>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>??
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>Todd Tillinghast wrote:
>>>>>>
>>>>>>>Following are valid:
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>><ref>Bible.KJV..Gen</ref>
>>>>>>><ref>Bible.KJV.A..Gen.a-a.1.1-1</ref>
>>>>>>><ref>Bible.B..Gen</ref>
>>>>>>><ref>Gen.20.17-18</ref>
>>>>>>><ref>Gen.20.17-18.Q-1</ref>
>>>>>>><rWork>Bible.TEV</rWork>
>>>>>>><rWork>Bible.XYZ</rWork>
>>>>>>><rWork>Bible.h</rWork>
>>>>>>><rWork>Bible.TEV.1998</rWork>
>>>>>>><rWork>Bible.1</rWork>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>Following are NOT valid:
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>><ref>Bible.KJV..</ref> (A side of me thinks this should be valid
>>>>>>>
>>as a
>>
>>>>>>>reference to the whole work.)
>>>>>>><ref>Bible.KJV.A..Gen.-a</ref>
>>>>>>><ref>Bible.TEV-1992..Gen</ref>
>>>>>>><ref>Gen.20.-18</ref>
>>>>>>><ref>Gen.20.17-18.-1</ref>
>>>>>>><ref>Gen.20.17-18-1</ref>
>>>>>>><ref>Gen 20:17</ref>
>>>>>>><rWork>Bible.TEV-1998</rWork>
>>>>>>><rWork>Bible.TEV 1998</rWork>
>>>>>>><rWork>Bible TEV</rWork>
>>>>>>><rWork>BIBLE.TEV</rWork>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>Todd
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>---------------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>>>---
>>>
>>>>>>> Name: osisScripture_01094.xsd
>>>>>>> osisScripture_01094.xsd Type: text/xml
>>>>>>> Encoding: quoted-printable
>>>>>>>
>>>>>--
>>>>>Patrick Durusau
>>>>>Director of Research and Development
>>>>>Society of Biblical Literature
>>>>>pdurusau@emory.edu
>>>>>
>>>--
>>>Patrick Durusau
>>>Director of Research and Development
>>>Society of Biblical Literature
>>>pdurusau@emory.edu
>>>
>
--
Patrick Durusau
Director of Research and Development
Society of Biblical Literature
pdurusau@emory.edu